Why Timing Hitting Isn’t Enough

Timing Hitting is a step up from MLB The Show 25 Stubs Directional in that it rewards players who can sync their swing to the pitch. But like Directional, it lacks PCI input.

Strengths: Easy to learn, rewarding for beginners who just want to make contact.

Weaknesses: No way to punish bad pitches effectively. You may time a hanging curveball perfectly, but without PCI control, you can’t guarantee it will leave the yard.

In competitive play, this translates to missed opportunities. Where Zone hitters crush mistakes, Timing hitters settle for weak contact or foul balls.

Why Meter Pitching Holds You Back

Meter Pitching is the traditional pitching interface many players grew up with. It uses a three-click system: start the meter, stop it for power, and stop it again for accuracy. While simple and familiar, it’s inherently limited.

Reduced Precision – The accuracy window is forgiving at lower difficulties, but on Hall of Fame or Legend, it becomes unreliable. Even perfect meter execution can still result in a missed location.

Predictability – Because the system lacks nuance, pitches often end up in hittable zones against skilled opponents.

Lower Control Ceiling – Like Timing Hitting, Meter Pitching caps your competitive ceiling. Even if you master the system, it won’t offer the pinpoint accuracy of Pinpoint Pitching.

For casual play, Meter Pitching works fine. But in MLB The Show 25 Stubs for sale online ranked matches, a hanging slider or misplaced fastball can be the difference between winning and losing.